| Platinum | Jack's Family Restaurant |
| Gold | Verona Pizza & Grill |
| Silver | Bianca's Pizza |
| Bronze | Franklin Pizzeria & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Dynamite |
| Top Pick | Levetto Waterloo |
| Top Pick | Pepi's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pizza Prosciutto |
| Top Pick | Pizzaville |
| Top Pick | Score Pizza |