| Platinum | Terrible Toby's |
| Gold | Creature Comfort Pet Emporium |
| Silver | Ren's Pets Depot |
| Bronze | Finnegan's Deli |
| Bronze | Global Pet Foods |
| Bronze | Piper's Pillows |
| Top Pick | Big Al's |
| Top Pick | CB Pet Food & Supplies |
| Top Pick | Pet Valu Bridgeport Road |
| Top Pick | Pet Valu Pioneer Park |