| Platinum | Vincenzo's |
| Gold | Hissing Goose Coffee Roasters |
| Silver | Mom's Bread and Pie Co |
| Bronze | Italo Food |
| Top Pick | All Things Tea |
| Top Pick | Aura-La Pastry and Provisions |
| Top Pick | Brady's Meat & Deli |
| Top Pick | Eby Street Bodega |
| Top Pick | Kitchen Kuttings Cafe |
| Top Pick | Torreense Store |