| Platinum | Jack's Family Restaurant |
| Gold | The Civil |
| Silver | Bauer Kitchen |
| Bronze | The Adventurers Guild Cafe |
| Top Pick | Abe Erb |
| Top Pick | Four Fathers Brewing Co. |
| Top Pick | Graffiti Market |
| Top Pick | Lancaster Smokehouse |
| Top Pick | The Lab Street Eats |
| Top Pick | The Ridge Social Eatery |