| Platinum | Lady Glaze Donuts |
| Gold | Debrodniks Donuts |
| Silver | Red Eye Donuts |
| Bronze | Anna Mae's Bakery & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Albert's Doughnuts Bake Shop |
| Top Pick | Elmira Donuts & Deli |
| Top Pick | LenJo Bakes |
| Top Pick | Mad Hatter Bake & Brew |
| Top Pick | Woodfire Bagels |
| Top Pick | Zehrs |