| Platinum | Four All Ice Cream |
| Gold | Ice Cream 2 |
| Silver | Dairy Queen |
| Bronze | Sweet Caroline's Ice Cream & Treats |
| Top Pick | Aura-La Pastry and Provisions |
| Top Pick | Baskin Robbins |
| Top Pick | Esta Chocolates |
| Top Pick | Mad Hatter Bake & Brew |
| Top Pick | Marbleslab |
| Top Pick | Scoops On Elmira |