| Platinum | The Crumby Cookie Dough Co. |
| Gold | Lenjobakes |
| Silver | Anna Mae's Bakery & Restaurant |
| Bronze | Foodland |
| Top Pick | Build a Bucket |
| Top Pick | Farm Boy |
| Top Pick | LenJo Bakes |
| Top Pick | Mad Hatter Bake & Brew |
| Top Pick | Sweet Lou's Cookies |
| Top Pick | University Square Bakery Deli |