| Platinum | Concordia Club |
| Gold | Metro Restaurant |
| Silver | Bread & Bretzel Basket |
| Bronze | Schwaben Club |
| Top Pick | Edelweiss Banquet Halls |
| Top Pick | J&B Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Siggi's Food Truck and Catering |
| Top Pick | The Olde Heidelberg Restaurant Tavern & Motel |
| Top Pick | Two Goblets Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Veslo Family Restaurant |