| Platinum | Verona Pizza & Grill |
| Gold | The Civil |
| Silver | Ennio's Pasta House |
| Bronze | East Side Mario's |
| Top Pick | 271West Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Dels Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Graffiti Market |
| Top Pick | La Cucina |
| Top Pick | Levetto Waterloo |
| Top Pick | Rustico Kitchen And Bar |